Discover how benchmarking can transform your executive search strategy, allowing you to assess and attract the best candidates from both employed and unemployed pools, ensuring a perfect fit for your company.

Why Traditional Hiring Fails: How Benchmarking Finds You the Best Leaders, Fast!

In executive recruitment, the conventional quest for the “perfect candidate” often revolves around matching comprehensive job descriptions with equally detailed resumes. This approach, while traditional, isn’t always the most effective or efficient. My experience, bolstered by methodologies like those outlined in “Executive Recruiting for Dummies,” suggests a more strategic approach: benchmarking. Benchmarking allows you to assess candidates against a broader set of criteria, including both employed and unemployed executives, ensuring a thorough evaluation of the available talent pool. Here’s why this method can redefine success in your hiring process and lead to better outcomes in less time.

The Limitations of the Conventional Candidate Search

  1. Narrow Focus: Traditional searches that concentrate only on candidates who actively apply can miss out on the best fits who might be passive talent, content in current roles but open to change for the right opportunity.
  2. Static Criteria: Relying strictly on resumes to match job descriptions overlooks dynamics like personality fit, leadership potential, and adaptability, which can be more critical to long-term success in the role.
  3. Time Inefficiencies: The standard approach often extends hiring timelines, as it limits the pool to active seekers and necessitates broader advertising and waiting periods for applications to arrive.

The Benchmarking Advantage

  1. Comprehensive Market Assessment: Benchmarking, as recommended in “Executive Recruiting for Dummies,” involves evaluating the entire market of potential candidates. This includes those currently employed (often the most qualified) and actively seeking new opportunities. By not limiting the search to the “actively looking” pool, you encompass a wider range of talent, increasing the chances of finding the best fit.
  2. Streamlined Search with Precise Metrics: Using benchmarking allows firms to set clear and precise standards for candidates based on proven competencies and potential cultural fit, rather than just hard skills or previous job titles. This method reduces time spent on less relevant candidates and focuses efforts on those who truly align with the company’s needs.
  3. Dynamic Fit Over Static Qualifications: Benchmarking prioritizes candidates’ future potential and their ability to grow within the company. This dynamic assessment looks at how candidates might adapt and evolve with the role, rather than just filling current requirements.

Implementing a Benchmarking Strategy in Executive Search

  1. Develop a Candidate Benchmark: Start by defining what success looks like in the role, including necessary skills, desired traits, and potential for growth. This benchmark should be comprehensive and flexible, accommodating a range of scenarios in which a candidate might excel.
  2. Assess the Entire Candidate Market: Utilize industry networks, social media platforms, and professional connections to identify both active and passive candidates who meet the benchmark criteria. This approach ensures no potential candidate is overlooked because they weren’t actively seeking new opportunities.
  3. Focus on Comprehensive Evaluation: Employ tools and techniques for evaluating candidates against the benchmark that include behavioral assessments, structured interviews, and possibly simulation exercises. These methods help identify candidates who not only fit the current needs but will also contribute to future strategic goals.

Bottomline on Benchmarking

Rethinking your approach to finding the perfect candidate by incorporating benchmarking strategies from “Executive Recruiting for Dummies” can significantly enhance the effectiveness and efficiency of your recruitment process. This method not only broadens your talent pool by including both employed and unemployed executives but also aligns candidate evaluation more closely with long-term strategic needs rather than just filling an immediate vacancy. By adopting this comprehensive approach, companies can reduce hiring timelines and increase the likelihood of finding the best candidate for their needs


Build your Search for Success: From the Inside Out

ottawa executive recruiters
Play Video