Think Bigger is Better for Executive Search? Here’s Why You’re Wrong!

Bigger Networks Can Overlook the Best Candidates: The Hidden Pitfalls of Large Executive Search Firms

In the executive search industry, the size of a firm’s network is often seen as a proxy for its capability and reach. A common assumption is that more contacts equal better access to top-tier talent. However, as a seasoned recruiter with extensive experience, I argue that larger networks and firms can actually hinder the search process more than they help it. This is not just due to the volume of candidates but also due to the ethical and practical limitations these firms face, notably “hands-off” restrictions that can severely limit their sourcing abilities. 

The Limitations of Large Networks

  1. Noise Over Signal: A vast network generates a high volume of candidates but not necessarily of the right quality. Sifting through numerous profiles to find the ideal candidate becomes more challenging and less efficient when the signal is diluted by noise.
  2. Over-Reliance on Automated Systems: To manage their extensive databases, large firms often depend on automated screening processes. These systems, while efficient, lack the nuance to detect candidates who do not meet conventional criteria but might be perfect for a specific role.
  3. Impersonal Candidate Experience: In large firms, the recruitment process can feel impersonal and generic. This can turn off high-caliber candidates who seek engagement and understanding of their unique career aspirations and values.

Ethical Restrictions and Competitive Disadvantages

  1. Hands-Off Restrictions: Large firms typically face extensive hands-off restrictions. For example, the two largest executive search firms each have about 36,000 hands-off restrictions over any given two-year period. This means they are ethically barred from soliciting employees from companies they’ve recently worked with, which often includes your direct competitors where the most desirable candidates might be found.
  2. Limited Access to Ideal Candidates: These ethical restrictions mean that the very candidates who could be most valuable to your organization may be off-limits if they are part of a firm’s existing client base. Thus, your access to potential top-tier talent is effectively reduced.
  3. Conflicts of Interest: Larger firms often work with multiple clients in the same industry, increasing the likelihood of conflicts of interest. This can compromise the firm’s ability to aggressively pursue the best candidates on your behalf if they are also serving your competitors.

Advantages of a Focused, Boutique Approach

A smaller, more boutique firm can offer a personalized and strategic approach to executive search that goes beyond the limitations faced by larger firms:

  1. Deeper Candidate Engagement: Smaller firms can afford the time and resources to engage deeply with each candidate, ensuring a thorough understanding of their capabilities and how they might fit into your organizational culture.
  2. Tailored Strategies: Without the burden of extensive hands-off restrictions, boutique firms can craft bespoke recruitment strategies that target the very best talent, including those within your competitors.
  3. Higher Quality Vetting: Focused firms can implement sophisticated vetting processes that look beyond resumes and interviews to include detailed assessments of potential strategic impact and cultural fit.


While large networks and firms have their place in the global marketplace, their inherent limitations mean they might not always be the best choice for your needs. If you are seeking not just to fill a leadership position but to strategically enhance your senior team, consider a boutique firm that can dedicate its efforts to finding not just any candidate, but the right candidate without the constraints of widespread hands-off policies.

Don’t let the best candidates slip through your network!

Partner with Perry-Martel International, where our focused approach ensures that no potential leader is overlooked. Reach out now to learn how our bespoke executive search strategies can benefit your organization.

Build your Search for Success: From the Inside Out

ottawa executive recruiters
Play Video