perfect candidate

Why the Perfect Candidate Might Not Be Who You Think: Rethinking the Ideal Profile in Executive Search


In the executive recruitment industry, the quest for the “perfect candidate” often drives the entire search process. Companies draft detailed job descriptions hoping to match them with the ideal resume, assuming that such a candidate will guarantee success. However, as a seasoned recruiter with extensive experience, I’ve come to a controversial but well-supported conclusion: the perfect candidate on paper might not be the best fit for your organization.

Here’s why rethinking your approach to defining the ideal candidate can lead to more effective and sustainable hiring decisions.


The Myth of the Perfect Resume

  1. Overlooking Potential for Growth: Candidates who check every box on the job description often do so because they’ve already mastered similar roles. While this might imply readiness, it can also signal a potential plateau in growth. Candidates who slightly under-qualify but show immense potential can bring growth, innovation, and a fresh perspective that seasoned experts might lack.
  2. The Fit Factor: Compatibility with a company’s culture and the team dynamics often trumps perfect qualifications. A candidate who fits perfectly on paper might struggle to integrate with the team or adapt to the company’s specific working style, leading to disruption and dissatisfaction on both sides.
  3. Static vs. Dynamic Needs: Business needs evolve, and a candidate who seems perfect today might not be right tomorrow. Focusing on adaptability and a capacity to learn and evolve within the role can be far more valuable than initial perfection.

Redefining ‘Perfection’ in Candidates

  1. Adaptability Over Expertise: In rapidly changing industries, the ability to adapt is invaluable. Candidates who have shown they can learn and thrive in varying environments may be a better long-term choice than those who have only excelled in stable, unchanging settings.
  2. Potential and Passion: Motivation and enthusiasm often lead to greater contributions than expertise alone. A passionate candidate who is eager to grow into a role can outperform a disengaged expert over time.
  3. Cultural Contribution: Beyond cultural fit, consider cultural contribution. What can a candidate bring to the table that will enhance or evolve the company’s culture? Diversity in thought and background can lead to more innovative teams and better problem-solving.

Implementing a Forward-Thinking Hiring Strategy

  1. Assess for Soft Skills: During interviews, prioritize attributes like problem-solving, leadership style, and adaptability. Behavioral interview techniques can reveal how a candidate might perform in real-world scenarios that reflect your company’s challenges.
  2. Dynamic Role Descriptions: Develop role descriptions that emphasize outcomes and objectives rather than just listing required qualifications. This encourages applications from candidates who are focused on growth and achievement.
  3. Structured Onboarding: Prepare for the integration of less-than-perfect candidates by planning robust onboarding processes that help them close any gaps and begin contributing quickly.


The “perfect candidate” is often more of a myth than a reality. By focusing on a broader set of qualities than just those that fit a rigid job description, companies can find candidates who will not only fill a current need but will also drive future growth. This approach ensures that the recruitment process aligns more closely with the dynamic, evolving needs of modern businesses.


Build your Search for Success: From the Inside Out

ottawa executive recruiters
Play Video